Could Planetary Alignments Truly Trigger Earthquakes? Separating Fact from Fiction
In the world of seismic predictions, there’s a remarkable character named Frank Hoogerbeets who claims that the positions of planets like Jupiter and Mars hold the key to understanding earthquakes. However, experts from various fields strongly dispute this notion. Let’s delve into this celestial controversy and explore the science behind it.
Frank Hoogerbeets’ Earthquake Predictions: Myth or Reality?
Frank Hoogerbeets recently drew attention by allegedly forecasting the Kahramanmaraş earthquakes a few days before they occurred. In a video released on February 12, Hoogerbeets ventured beyond Turkey’s borders and predicted possible major earthquakes in neighboring countries.
According to him, a shift in pressure distribution, a consequence of the Kahramanmaraş earthquakes, could trigger significant seismic events in Lebanon or Egypt. Hoogerbeets justified his predictions by highlighting the historical seismic activity in these regions.
Debunking Hoogerbeets’ Claims
While Hoogerbeets’ statements raised concerns, Dr. Sharif El-Hadi, the head of Egypt’s earthquake department, was quick to dismiss these predictions. He firmly stated that there is no scientific evidence to support the idea of an imminent earthquake in Egypt. El-Hadi emphasized, “There are no tools in the world that can predict earthquakes,” adding that Hoogerbeets’ claims lack scientific foundation.
El-Hadi further noted that Egypt is relatively far from earthquake-prone areas and that the severity of earthquakes in Turkey is unlikely to be replicated there.
The Influence of Planetary Alignments
Frank Hoogerbeets bases his earthquake predictions on planetary alignments, which he regularly shares via YouTube and Twitter. He has gained popularity as the “earthquake oracle” among his followers, yet experts dispute his qualifications.
Hoogerbeets openly admits that he lacks an academic title and refers to himself as an “earthquake enthusiast.” He attributes tremors to celestial bodies like Mars and Venus, citing the 7.5-magnitude earthquake and tsunami in Palu Bay, Indonesia in 2018 as an example. Hoogerbeets believes that the gravitational forces of Venus, Uranus, Neptune, and Mars played a role in this disaster.
Also read |
A Powerful Earthquake Shakes Pakistan
SSGEOS | Solar System Geometry Survey
Fortunately relatively deep, so probably not much damage
The Moon’s Role in Earthquakes
The relationship between the Moon’s tidal forces and earthquakes has been debated among astronomers for years. US geophysicist Andrew Michael points out that even finding a small correlation requires extensive statistical analysis of vast datasets, and results have remained inconclusive.
Michael clarifies, “So overall, the Moon does not have a significant enough effect on earthquakes to be used for prediction.” Considering the Moon’s proximity to Earth, the influence of more distant planets on seismic activity is even less likely.
To put things into perspective, Jupiter, the largest planet in our solar system, exerts only 1 percent of the Moon’s gravitational pull when it is at its closest position to Earth. Venus follows with a mere 0.6 percent. Other planets have even less influence. Given the limited impact of the Moon, it seems implausible that more distant celestial bodies could affect earthquakes on Earth.
In the end, while planetary alignments and celestial bodies may be intriguing, the scientific community remains skeptical of their role in predicting earthquakes. As we continue to explore the mysteries of our planet’s seismic activity, it’s crucial to rely on well-established scientific methods and expertise rather than unverified claims.